jprussell: (Default)
[personal profile] jprussell
As we return to glorious standard time, where the sun actually reflects what time of day it is at this time of year, I have found myself with a nagging sinus headache all day, which hot compresses, eye drops, and copious hydration have done little to help. I blame Daylight Savings, and that brings me to the topic for this short placeholder post: Daylight Savings Delenda Est.

For those who were not the beneficiaries of a classical education, that is a play on Carthago Delenda Est, which is a shortening of Ceterum censeo Carthaginem esse delendam, a quote that means "Furthermore, I consider that Carthage must be destroyed," which was something Cato the Elder used to end every single speech he gave in the senate between the end of the Second Punic War and the beginning of the Third.

Anyway, I doubt I feel as strongly about Daylight Savings as Cato felt about the Punic Wars (or about anything - dude was intense), but I do think it's actually, legitimately bad and harmful. When it starts, kids have to walk to school or wait for buses in the dark. The shock of losing an hour of sleep and hard rebooting your circadian rhythm apparently causes all kinds of health problems, including a not-proven-to-be-causal correlation with an increase in heart attacks. Perhaps most importantly, but least directly, the very idea that we can and should unmoor time from the rhythms of the sun on which it is based is technocratic, modernist hubris of the worst kind.

All that being said, I'm a reasonable man. While my preference is definitely for eliminating Daylight Savings and going back to having standard time all year round, I am willing to settle for any solution that eliminates the time changes back and forth. If there's more political will around making it Daylight Savings year round and eliminating Standard Time, fine, I won't fight you too hard. Let's just get back to where the association of clock time and amount of daylight changes the way it should - slowly, day-by-day, as the seasons turn.

And so, Daylight Savings Delenda Est!

I fervently agree

Date: 2023-11-06 08:34 am (UTC)
miow: Bubbles (Default)
From: [personal profile] miow
Yes!! I emigrated to the UK from a country that does not subscribe to this nonsense. 20 years later and I still hate 'daylight savings '. I could never articulate why though, so am very glad to have read your post now. Even the name is hubristic. As if people could actually save light. I don't know if our term is any better: British summer time. (Which is a joke if you think about it. A cruel joke too).

Date: 2023-11-06 12:17 pm (UTC)
sdi: Oil painting of the Heliconian Muse whispering inspiration to Hesiod. (Default)
From: [personal profile] sdi
Fifteen years ago, when I was merely hostile to DST, my arguments were the same as yours. It's simply inhumane.

But then I started a business, a major component of which was an international, networked service that one could query for information—of which knowing the time was an essential part. Because of this, we had to be timezone-aware (and DST is a property of many time zones).

The problem with time zones and DST is that everything you think you know about them is wrong. A day is 24 hours long, right? WRONG, because of DST, it can be 23 hours or 25 hours. Every day starts at midnight, right? WRONG, some days (in some time zones) start at 1AM! Hours tick sequentially, right? WRONG, because of DST, some hours don't exist, while others exist twice (e.g. on a DST day, you get 2AM followed by 2AM again, or whatever). The timezone offset of a given place is fixed, right? WRONG, because of DST, a place may be at one offset at one time and a different offset at another time. Well, at least it's consistent year-to-year, right? WRONG, the date of DST changes, and further these are all political constructs, and are subject to change as new laws get passed (or as new governments come into being), and so if your service has historical information (as ours did), you need to keep a giant database of how these political changes occur over time. (Don't get me started about that time a decade ago that a military coup took over Egypt and instituted DST retroactively because they couldn't keep the lights on, thus causing the staff of the entire internet to scramble like mad for a month to fix it so Egyptian clocks would work once again.) Every place has one timezone, though, right? HAHA WRONG, as I said, these are political constructs, and different people disagree about who is in charge—so some places are disputed and therefore the clock time of a place is in dispute, too. (And it's not just over pieces of land, too—for example, in Xinjiang, China, the clock time depends on your ethnicity rather than your location.) And guess what, if you give somebody the wrong time—either due to a mistake or due to any of the above complexities—it can be construed as a political statement and get you jail time (or worse).

And lest you think this is merely an international issue, did you know there are over 30 time zones in the United States alone, not counting disputed territories?

In the end we spent between a substantial fraction of our efforts—maybe a quarter?—just working out what time it is, let alone what our service was actually supposed to be doing. That's a heck of a tax on starting a small business, or any kind of economic activity—which, of course, is what the whole timezone and DST business is supposed to facilitate!

No, if there's anything I've learned in my time as a human, it's that humans are too stupid to be capable of self-governance, and time is too important to be left to the politicians. We ought to leave it to the gods, and so the only timepiece I consider acceptable any longer is the Great Atomic Clock in the Sky. Anyway, it's more accurate, it's easier to calculate the current time, there's no need to add leap seconds (a WHOLE OTHER nightmare, by the way), and, unlike our atomic clocks, it doesn't cost us an absolute fortune to run.
Edited (I could keep adding to my rant all day, I'll try to resist :)) Date: 2023-11-06 01:26 pm (UTC)

Meant to add:

Date: 2023-11-06 05:58 pm (UTC)
miow: Bubbles (Default)
From: [personal profile] miow
I hope you feel better soon!

Profile

jprussell: (Default)
Jeff Russell

March 2025

S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
232425262728 29
3031     

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 7th, 2025 09:05 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios
OSZAR »